Using signal detection theory to understand grade crossing warning time and motorist stopping behavior.
-
2015-02-01
Details:
-
Creators:
-
Corporate Creators:
-
Subject/TRT Terms:
-
Publication/ Report Number:
-
Resource Type:
-
Geographical Coverage:
-
Corporate Publisher:
-
Abstract:Motorist error or poor judgment is a significant causal factor in highway-rail grade crossing collisions. Crashes at grade crossings
equipped with warning devices often involve motorists who drive around gates or across railroad tracks while flashing lights are warning
them that a train is approaching. This noncompliant behavior may be due to the motorists’ expectations of train arrival time following
activation of gates and lights as well as the overall duration of the warning. Because warning times are variable, it is uncertain whether
the mean warning duration, the variability of the warning’s duration, or both are influencing motorists’ decisions to disregard the
warnings. As a result, signal detection theory was used to model motorists’ stopping behavior at active grade crossings. The key factor
in predicting motorist stopping behavior is treating the subjective probability that a train is in the grade crossing as a function of the
expected arrival time of the train and this was modeled with Gaussian, Chi-squared and Poisson probability distributions. The
probability of stopping predicted from each probability distribution was compared with data collected by Richards and Heathington
(1990). The Gaussian model provided the best fit to the data and indicated that warning time variability is the most important factor
affecting motorist stopping behavior. Additional data collection to confirm and refine the model is discussed. A theory of motorist
behavior at grade crossings, such as signal detection theory, provides a means to critically examine inchoate hypotheses so that they can
be more formally stated and vigorously tested. This theory should continue to be developed for evaluating motorist behavior at grade
crossings.
-
Format:
-
Collection(s):
-
Main Document Checksum:
-
Download URL:
-
File Type: